November, 1998 - Vol. XXVII No. 2
Total Ministry: A New Way of Being Together
"The Circular Model of
Organizing"
by Ann Smith
The circular model builds community in which all people are invited to be part of a living system that allows and enables their full participation interacting independently in carrying out the shared dream. Participants value enlightenment more than conflict, and engage fully in co-creating life-giving structures that affirm community.
Living systems are in constant process of discovery and creating new ideas, new opportunities and new relationships. Living systems enhance the individual's participation by affirming their skills, talents and gifts and by providing opportunities to try new leadership roles seeking out the best of what is and what might become. Positive images of shared leadership, a spiritual depth of personal sharing, and a sense of play allows everyone to feel valued and to explore the impossible, expanding the collective imagination. All experience is seen as a source of knowledge and personal storytelling is the authentic voice. Appreciate Inquiry, a dialogue that focuses on the positive, allows for full potential of all individuals to co-create a desired future and to make the dream come true.
The circular model is as old as the hills and as new as the 21st
century. The following examples are a means to show differences between the hierarchical
and the circular leadership models of community organizing.
| Hierarchical Leadership | Circular Leadership |
| Top-Middle-Bottom | All are equal |
| Leaders and followers | Full participation |
| Power over | Power with |
| Machine | Living system |
| Rigid Control | Fluid |
| Organize around a problem | Organize around a dream |
| The world as it is | The world as it should be |
| Quid pro quo | Conversion, transformation |
| Self-interest | God's will |
| Allies | Community |
| Political | Spiritual |
| Aggressive/Passive-aggressive | Assertive/Passive-assertive |
| Closed information system | Open communication system |
| Entitled officers | Authentic leaders |
| Decisions by leaders | Decisions by consensus |
| Scarcity theology | Abundance theology |
| Euro-centric perspective | Multi-cultural perspective |
| Competition | Collaboration |
| Celebration of victories | Celebration of community |

The transition from the hierarchy to a circular
model in existing organizations is not easy because the resistance to change is present at
all levels. Individuals at the top are afraid they will loose power and control. People in
the middle fear they will no longer have a role to play, and individuals at the bottom of
the structure have lost faith in their superiors in looking out for their best interest or
involvement. Most people in top-down organizations have not had many experiences that
confirm their trust in the circular model, or have had pseudo-experiences in which the
words and the behaviors did not match. Fear of the unknown and lack of trust are also
present in creating new structures. It takes time and patience to transform fears into
mutual support and trust. The Seven Principles of the Circular Model provide the steps
needed for the new leadership in designing and carrying out highly successful events.
Seven Guiding Principle to Create and Sustain the Circular Model of Leadership
Sacred Space: Create sacred space in all setting so that spirituality is the focus. Help
create a place where the Holy Spirit guides who we are and who we are to become. Arrange
seating in a circle, or in a series of circles in a large gathering. Provide rituals,
centering music, prayers, meditations and community celebrations that enable everyone to
fully engage in the process from beginning to end. Provide a ritual that discharges
negative energy and allows the group to move forward. This can be as simple as asking
everyone to write down on a piece of paper any negative thoughts that they have brought to
this gathering, acknowledging that we all bring baggage that can be left behind. The
papers are then thrown away or burned.
Shared Leadership: Share the leadership. Each person is equally valued for her- or himself
and equally shares the power within the community. Decisions are made by consensus and all
information and resources are shared. Individual talents, skills and gifts are recognized
and empowered. Power is derived from the consent of others and leaders act as
facilitators, modeling power-with and not power-over. Mutual support and trust by every
person insures a healthy and highly productive living system.
Vision: Create a vision together. When we dream it together, then it happens. A shared
vision owned and articulated by everyone guarantees excellence in leadership. The vision
becomes the navigational chart for sailing into the unknown waters of the future. The
future promises to be as unpredictable as the weather, constantly changing, but with a
clear vision that the organization will stay on course - a divine path.
Norms: Establish working norms together - standards of behavior agreed upon be the group
or organization. They are reflective of the group's values, beliefs and ethics. Norms
invite members to share the responsibility for developing relationships of mutual support
and trust that build community and foster circular leadership. Norms shape the way a group
makes decisions and solves problems. Norms are constantly reviewed and updated. Staying in
the circle in times of conflict, and using assertiveness skills along with compassion,
provide the emotional atmosphere needed for a healthy and productive organization.
Accountability: Everyone is accountable to the vision, the shared leadership, and to all
the tasks. Accountability is two-way and circular in structure. "First among
equals" means that the organization has an elected or appointed head who relates to
outside structures and entities and has oversight for the entire operation. This person,
or persons, such as with co-chairs, are empowered by the organization to act on its
behalf, honoring the consensus model of decision making. All task-related groups also
designate a head who reports out and receives information. Mutual accountability to one
another is very important so that the quality of the interactions remains positive and
creative solutions to problems are found.
Theological Reflection, Evaluation, Celebration: Theological reflection, evaluation and
celebration are done at all gatherings and meetings. What is working? What needs to be
done? What are we called to be? to do? The process is the means and the ends, and is held
in trust by all the members of the organization. Reflection provides the illumination
needed to stay on the course. Assertive skills in giving and receiving positive and
critical feedback along with active listening assures that the integrity of individuals
remains congruant with the circular model.
Creativity: Creativity comes from God and resides within everyone. As co-creators with
God, everyone receives the power and the authority to carry out the vision. The creative
arts - art, dance, writing, poetry, music, drawing with the non-dominant hand, drama,
meditation, role playing, shower of ideas and listening in new ways - bring out the divine
spark of creativity. Creativity brings new thinking and new behaviors that transform
established organizations and develop new structures that constantly change in
relationship to the divine plan.
| Ann is the director of Women in Mission and Ministry at the Episcopal Church Center in New York. |
© 2001, Diocese of Oregon
updated 05/03/2003 16:26
contact: kylew@diocese-oregon.org